It’s understandably frustrating when you begin losing members despite having strong programming and are forced to ask yourself why members don’t renew. It can be even more head scratching when you realize that renewal challenges are often not about dues. In fact, that is frequently the case. Instead, earning consistent renewals is more about connection, experience and perceived value. The following will cover some of the top reasons your members might be choosing to leave, along with practical ways to fix them.
Why Member Retention Matters
Member retention is one of the clearest signals of your organization’s long-term health. When members stay, your community grows stronger, revenue becomes more predictable and engagement deepens. Retention also reduces pressure on constant acquisition and creates a more stable foundation for future growth. Simply put, when retention is strong, everything is easier to scale.
Members Don’t Renew When They Don’t Feel Engaged
Statistically speaking, lack of engagement is noted as the number one predictor of non-renewals. Participation is not the same thing as connection. Engagement is a two-way relationship and members deserve to see you noticing their participation and encouraging it throughout your ongoing relationship. Your members do not want to feel as if they are merely existing within an organization or are only a number. They want to feel like an active part of the community, a participant rather than a spectator. In addition, members who are not taking advantage of all their member benefits are not experiencing the value of their membership, which can lead to them opting out of renewal.
How to Fix It: Offer a variety of touchpoints like surveys, forums, volunteering and microlearning. Track members within your Association Management Software to spot inactive members and create personalized onboarding pathways for new members, encouraging connection early on. The onboarding process is key because this is where you showcase the benefits members can take advantage of and set the stage for continued engagement and renewals.
- Offer a variety of engagement touchpoints
- Track inactive members in your AMS
- Create personalized onboarding pathways
Members Don’t Renew When They Don’t See the Value
Members failing to realize the value of their membership is another major reason they might not renew. The value perception of your organization is incredibly important when it comes to clearly outlining what members get in exchange for their dues. Not presenting a clear value and incentive programs as part of a membership is a major issue that can lead to a drop in renewals. You want to ensure that members understand exactly what they gain from membership and what they would lose if they do not renew.
How to Fix It: Refresh your member value proposition annually to stay relevant. Highlight clear ROI stories such as how a specific member grew their business after attending a key event or using a specific benefit. Showcase real member results across your channels. Promote overarching benefits everywhere including member portals, invoices, renewal emails and member events. Survey members at least once a year to discover changing priorities and identify what continues to resonate or needs attention.
- Refresh your value proposition annually
- Highlight real ROI stories
- Promote benefits across every channel
- Survey members each year
Members Don’t Renew When the Experience is Frustrating
If the process of renewing is frustrating, involving clunky logins, outdated payment options or confused renewal outlines, it can lead to many members simply opting out of renewing. A seamless digital experience builds trust and communicates professionalism. Again, business owners are immensely busy, so if the process of renewing their membership becomes too time-consuming, they will simply forgo the hassle associated with membership renewal.
How to Fix it: Offer auto-renewals and online payments, reduce form fields and allow mobile renewals. Use friendly branded confirmation messages instead of generic receipts. Consider conducting a member experience audit to test your own site for the issues outlined above. The easier you make the process, the more likely members are to complete it.
- Offer auto renewals and online payments
- Reduce form fields and support mobile renewals
- Use branded confirmation messages
- Conduct a member experience audit
Members Don’t Renew When Budgets Get Tight
Financial constraints can be another reason a member may choose not to renew. This is especially common for smaller organizations or independent professionals. Communicating the ongoing impact or value of membership can help justify the expense when budgets are tight. Right now, financial strain is one of the most common reasons businesses decide not to renew. Sometimes it is also the result of an employer no longer paying for membership. No matter the situation, budget pressure can quickly lead to a lapse. For many organizations, this financial pressure quietly becomes the deciding factor in why members don’t renew.
How to Fix It: Offer tiered membership levels or a lite option so members can remain engaged even with limited budgets. Allow flexible payment schedules with quarterly or monthly options to make renewals more manageable. Focus your messaging on renewal as an investment in success rather than a cost.
- Offer tiered or lite membership options
- Allow quarterly or monthly payments
- Position renewal as an investment
Members Don’t Renew When They Simply Forget
Another reason members may not renew is simply because they forget. Business owners are often pulled in many directions at once and with so many responsibilities, it is understandable that renewal can slip through the cracks.
How to Fix It: Set up automated renewal reminders for 90, 60 and 30 days before expiration. While it is important not to overwhelm members, well timed reminders are often helpful rather than annoying. Add renewal banners to your portal and confirmation pages so they are visible but not disruptive. Offer a one click renewal option for logged in members to make the process as quick and easy as possible. Proactive reminders protect revenue with minimal effort.
- Set automated reminders for 90, 60 and 30 days
- Add renewal banners to portals and confirmation pages
- Provide easy renewal options
Members Don’t Renew When Their Needs Change, and You Don’t Adapt
Sometimes members do not renew because their needs have changed and your organization has not adapted. Industries evolve and member expectations change along with them. Adapting your benefits shows responsiveness and helps keep your membership relevant. This does not mean changing everything constantly. It means staying in tune with trends and adjusting strategically. Organizations that assume they have already reached their peak often struggle most with retention.
How to Fix it: Review your content and programs regularly to ensure continued relevance. Create feedback loops such as annual surveys or short pulse polls. Consider forming member focus groups by career stage or segment. These insights help you understand which trends are here to stay and where adjustments may be needed.
- Review programs regularly for relevance
- Run annual surveys or short pulse polls
- Create member focus groups by segment
How to Turn Insights into Action
Now that we have considered what can cause problems in terms of membership retention due to lack of membership renewals, it’s helpful to look at some key insights that you can put into action. Implementing these will help you turn the trajectory away from lack of renewals and improve your overall membership renewal rate. The following are some easy-to-implement insights you can put into action that will help you counteract the problems outlined regarding common renewal issues:
Map The Renewal Journey
The first action to take is to map the renewal journey for your membership. This includes visualizing each touchpoint your members will journey through, beginning at the joining process, then considering engagement and onto renewing. You want to visualize and walk through the entire journey as this can highlight any friction points that might be present and give you the opportunity to improve the overall member experience. You should redo this over and over regularly to ensure that a problem doesn’t present itself at a later date as well. It’s not a one-and-done task.
Use Data to Drive Retention
Track engagement, attendance and email interactions through your AMS or data insights tools. Use this invaluable information and turn into action by personalizing your outreach and improving your program or ease-of-use. Allow this data to shape how you move forward in several ways. Gathering this data is key in order to get the information you need to make effective changes to your subscription service.
Build a Year-Round Retention Strategy
Instead of looking at a renewal date as a singular date in time that you build up to, realize that renewal is more than a date. It actually is a process that begins on day one of membership, not 30 days before a membership expires. There are several ways to build this year-round retention strategy, including performing quarterly check-ins to evaluate various member health metrics.
Are You Ready to Make Renewals Effortless?
After gaining a new member, you want to do everything possible to retain them and encourage long term loyalty. As outlined above, renewal challenges are rarely about dues alone. They are usually the result of several connected factors that influence experience and value.
At MemberClicks, we are passionate about helping associations strengthen engagement and retention. If you are ready to take your retention strategy even further, download our Member Retention Guide to learn practical strategies for boosting engagement and keeping more members year after year.
Need Help?